Starting November 2, 2026, Manheim is changing how AutoGrade scores are calculated. ADESA condition reports (CRs), inspection processes, and arbitration guidelines are not changing. This page explains what is different, what is not, and what it means whether you are buying or selling.
Background: What is AutoGrade?
What’s Changing
Beginning November 2, 2026, AutoGrade will consider only two mechanical factors: whether the vehicle drives forward and whether the airbags have been deployed. Other mechanical factors will no longer be part of the score. Cosmetic criteria are unchanged.
Because AutoGrade scores appear across the wholesale marketplace, including on ADESA, what a score means will change everywhere you see it. A vehicle’s grade may look different after Nov. 2 even though the vehicle itself has not changed.

For full details, see Manheim’s announcement.
What Isn’t Changing
- ADESA condition reports. CRs stay the same and offer the same insight.
- ADESA inspection process. Nothing about how we inspect vehicles is changing.
- ADESA arbitration guidelines. Vehicles cannot be arbitrated on the basis of AutoGrade today, and that will not change. We will keep disclosing reliable information on the vehicles we offer. See our arbitration guidelines.
General Impact
In general, AutoGrade scores will be higher than under the old model, but the impact is uneven. Vehicles that have more mechanical damages will see a bigger change, while those without mechanical issues will see a smaller change, or perhaps no change at all.
As a rule of thumb:
- No change: Cars with no recorded mechanical issues.
- Modest change: Cars with some recorded mechanical issues but no damage to the engine or drivetrain.
- Large change: Cars with recorded engine or drivetrain issues.
If You’re Selling
Grades on your vehicles may look different after Nov. 2. Keep using the full condition report, images, and disclosures to price and describe your vehicles, since they give buyers the complete picture.
Consider pricing using CarValue. CarValue is a predictive model of the expected sale price of a vehicle at ADESA, as opposed to a historical average of transactions like traditional guidebooks. We have updated CarValue Wholesale to rely less on AutoGrade and more on underlying mechanical factors—for example, damages to the engine or drivetrain and warning lights. We anticipate this change will result in prices close to those CarValue and other books produced before the AutoGrade update.
We will share more as we learn how the change affects CarValue results.
If You’re Buying
A grade will reflect less mechanical information than before. Buy with confidence by reviewing the full condition report, images, and announcements to evaluate each vehicle, using tools like CarValue to help make informed decisions, and using enhanced features like engine audio on timed listings.
As mechanical issues are a large factor in vehicle values, we have updated CarValue Wholesale to account for the changes. The score now reads engine or drivetrain issues and dashboard warning lights directly from the condition report rather than AutoGrade. We anticipate average CarValue prices will remain largely consistent with those produced before the update.
Take a fresh look at your saved searches, particularly those that rely heavily on AutoGrade score. Marketplace.ADESA.com offers a few dozen specific filters that can help you find inventory that meets your needs. Our team is available to help set you up for success.
Our Commitment to Transparency
Whatever tools sit alongside a grade, our goal is the same: give buyers and sellers the information they need to make confident decisions.
We prioritize consistency and transparency in our CRs, and offer analytics tools like CarValue and features like engine audio on timed listings that enable informed decision making. We’ll continue to keep accuracy and integrity at the core of our processes to support both buyers and sellers.
We Want to Hear From You
Tell your ADESA representative how this change affects you. We value your feedback and will keep this page up to date as we learn more.
Frequently Asked Questions
What about cars previously listed?
We’ll update AutoGrade scores for all current inventory, beginning November 2. It may take 2-3 days to update all inventory. All ADESA inventory will consistently use the new scoring model after the change.
Are inspections changing?
No. We’ll continue performing the same high-quality inspections we do today.
Is anything changing on the VDP?
The new AutoGrade model and CarValue will populate on VDPs going forward. After the transition, we’ll make sure buyers are aware of the changes with a variety of messages online and in-lane.
How will this affect scores?
In general, we expect scores to go up, though the impact won’t be uniform across units.
Will any scores go down?
Only in a few circumstances. Notably, cars checked in with no key may initially receive a lower grade than in the past. However, after keys are made and the CR is updated to indicate the car is drivable, the score will update to something more typical.
How will it affect different types of vehicles?
Vehicles with mechanical issues will be impacted more significantly, particularly those with engine/drivetrain issues. Vehicles with fewer or no mechanical issues will be scored much closer to how they are currently.
What about CarValue?
CarValue prices will remain consistent throughout this process. Vehicles with prior mechanical issues will continue to receive comparable CarValue Wholesale pricing following the change to AutoGrade. CarValue Retail is unaffected by this change.
What about other book values?
It’s likely there will be swings in other grade-adjusted book values as the market normalizes to these updates. Consider using CarValue, which we expect will produce prices closer to those from MMR before the change.
Will this change arbitration practices or guidelines?
No, this won’t change our arbitration policies. Vehicles cannot be arbitrated on the basis of AutoGrade today and that won’t change with Manheim’s upcoming changes. We’ll continue to disclose reliable information on vehicles we offer. See our arbitration guidelines for more details.
If I have more questions about a specific car or cars, where do I go?
The best way to find detail on a specific unit is to thoroughly review the condition report.